|
Below are basic questions
about specific items concerning Passion week events and their explanation
in the context of two contiguous Passovers in the year of the
Crucifixion.
|
Item
|
Explanation
|
 | What are the annual Sabbaths in the Bible and
their meaning? |
|
See
Annual Festival Calendar and Its Symbolism. |
 |
Can you layout the
Crucifixion week in the form of a chart? This would be helpful for me to
get an overview of those events. |
|
Sure. See
The Crucifixion Week. |
 |
Why
does no New Testament account of the Last Supper mention a Pascal lamb?
|
|
The
Essene Passover was meatless as they were vegetarians. Moreover, as the
high priest did not slay the first of the Passover lambs until the
afternoon of Nisan 14 on the priestly calendar there could be no Torah
compliant Pascal lamb for the Essene Passover. The idea that Jesus and
his followers would independently slay a lamb and have their own
Torah-compliant Passover before the high priest slew the first Passover
lamb in a ritual ceremony is problematic. That idea has its basis in the
argument that the institution of Passover in Moses' day occurred in the
night of Nisan 14 not Nisan 15. |
 |
Why was ordinary bread used and not unleavened
bread?
|
|
This
question assumes a fact not in evidence. The word used for bread in
normal parlance, artos, can refer to either leavened or unleavened bread.
While some passionately argue that artos can refer only to leavened
bread Luke makes it quite clear that this is not the case at
Luke 24:30 where the resurrected Jesus Christ dined at Emmanus. There
during the Days of Unleavened Bread, Jesus takes artos, which his
two Torah-compliant Jewish hosts gave him to break. He proceeds to break
it and hand pieces to his hosts. The
context of the Passover and Days of Unleavened Bread necessitate for
artos here to be unleavened bread as Torah
requires it. Moreover, the normal bread we know today is white, fluffy,
and puffed-up, but that was not the case with leavened bread two thousand
years ago (see
Colbert 2002:22). The leavened bread of that time was a flat bread,
similar to pita bread but thin, that one had to tear not brake. Try
breaking normal pita bread or a leavened flower tortilla (if you can break
them then they have been so
overheated that they are not ordinarily eaten). Physically unleavened bread
could be broken but leavened bread could not. Anciently, one broke unleavened bread
and tore leavened bread. So then, both at the first Christian Passover and
in the meal at Emmanus Jesus broke artos. How can the fact that the
artos at the Last Supper was unleavened bread be any more
unmistakable? The Essenes were Torah-compliant in their Seder except for
the Pascal lamb itself. |
 |
Why was only one cup
used?
|
|
The
cup was evidently the one Jesus used during the course of the meal.
Since it was the one he had at hand he decided to use it, filled with
wine, to introduce a change of symbolism. The use of the single cup
certainly suggests intimacy. |
 |
How could Jesus have been arrested after the
Passover feast had
begun?
|
|
There
were two back-to-back Passovers in the year of the Crucifixion. This was
possible in the Hebrew Calendar in CE 30 and in CE 31. |
 |
How could a linen cloth be purchased for his
burial?
|
|
The
traditional Passover of the Jews had not yet started and buying and
selling was still underway in Jerusalem. |
 |
How
could Jesus' disciples have thought that Judas left the Last Supper to
buy things needed for the feast? |
|
The traditional Passover of the Jews had not yet begun. The annual
Passover Sabbath
(The Feast of Unleavened Bread) began 24 hours after the Lord's Supper. |
 |
How
could Simon of Cyrene be found coming from work in the fields on
apparently a holiday?
|
|
It
was not yet the annual Passover Sabbath which began at the end of Nisan 14 known
as the Feast of Unleavened Bread. As a traditional Jew he was free to
work on Nisan 14 and then rest on the annual Sabbath (Nisan 15). |
 |
How
could Jesus have stated, according to Matthew's gospel, that he
would be in the heart of the earth three days and three nights? |
|
A
Tuesday night Last Supper necessitates a Wednesday afternoon
Crucifixion. Three full days and three full nights in the tomb brings
the Resurrection to the nether period between sunset and dark (when the
last part of the sun disappears below the horizon at the end of the
weekly Sabbath). |
 |
How
could three days have passed from his death to his resurrection in
the context of Luke 24:21? |
|
William F. Arndt and F.
Wilber Gingrich state in their A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament
explain the following:
Perh. impers. [Perhaps impersonal(ly)] this
is the third day Lk 24:21; but, since this expr. [expression] cannot be
found elsewhere, it is prob. [probably] better to supply Ihsou'"
as subj. [subject] (B1-D. �129 app.) lit. [literally] Jesus is
spending the third day... (Arndt
and Gingrich 1979:14.)
From the perspective of Sunday afternoon "Jesus is spending
the third day" had already passed. In modern English the sense of the
expression is "the third day has already passed" thus the alternate
translation of
Luke 24:21 is,
as it should be exegetically (as it conforms the verse to the context of
all the Gospels data telling of the Passion week): "But we were hoping that it was He who was
going to redeem Israel. Indeed, besides all this, the third day has passed
since these things happened." This rendering, showing the dismay of two
disciples that Jesus' body was gone and the three days and three nights
period was past, is confirmation of Matthew's non-metaphorical literal
language at Matthew 12:40. This rendering eradicates any evidentiary
value of the Luke 24:21 for demonstrating a Sunday resurrection as it
neutralizes the probative value of the passage for that argument. |
 |
How could the first day of the feast of unleavened
bread be the day on which the Passover lamb had to be sacrificed
when the Days of Unleavened Bread began Nisan 15 (Leviticus; Mark
14:12; Matthew 26:17; Luke 22:7)? |
|
The simplest, most
straightforward answer is that on the traditional Jewish calendar the annual Sabbath, the
Feast of
Unleavened Bread, for the Essenes was Nisan 14. This means in the year of the Crucifixion there were eight
days of unleavened bread and on the first of the eight days the Passover
lambs were to be sacrificed.
|
 |
Was the stone in front of Jesus' tomb round? |
|
A couple of women could
have moved a large rolling stone set in a track of the type used
in the Herodian period. The women couldn't move the stone blocking
Jesus' tomb, however, as it was a
huge block not round. Note that an angel sat on the stone, which
he had rolled away from the door of the tomb, as if it were a bench (Matthew
28:2). Moreover, one can roll a block.
|
 |
Why do you insist that the year of the Crucifixion
was CE 30? Doesn't the Seventy Weeks prophecy in Daniel 9 fix CE 31
as the year our Savior died? |
|
Biblical
prophecy is an important concern to those who believe in biblical
prophecy. It is not subject, however, to the strictures of replication
and verification required by the scientific method. We
understand that for those sensitive to the implications of biblical prophecy
it is a different matter. So let's explore the prophecy of Daniel 9. To
do so requires more space than we have here so go to
The
Seventy Weeks Prophecy. |
 |
Daniel 9 states that the Messiah would be cut off in
the midst of the week. This requires a 3 1/2 year ministry yet you
make it 2 1/2 years to come up with a contrived CE 30 date. Why? |
|
You
assume Daniel 9 deals with Jesus of Nazareth. The evidence suggests
otherwise. A careful exegesis of Daniel 9 shows that in context the
prophecy deals with the Temple in the times of the Maccabees. See
The
Seventy Weeks Prophecy. |
 |
Just what purpose does inventing an Essene connection to
Jesus serve? A large dining hall in Jerusalem could just as easily have
been owned by a rich man such as Joseph of Arimathea. |
|
Our article presented the
evidence that Jesus kept his last Seder at the Essene guesthouse. This
is a wholly different matter than labeling Jesus an Essene. In context, the Gospels show that Jesus
observed a Passover Seder 24 hours before the traditional Passover Seder
of the Jews. Based upon the current state of scholarly knowledge, unless
there were two back-to-back Passover days in the year of the Crucifixion
there appears to be no reconciliation of the Gospel accounts. The only
known Jewish group to have kept a meatless Passover in Jerusalem's Upper City
during the Herodian Period were the Essenes. See
The Crucifixion Week.
|
 | Why did the women not anoint Jesus' body on
Friday? Why wait and show up at the tomb on Sunday morning four days
later? Didn't they know his body would be stinking by then? |
|
Of course his body would be
stinking after four days. That parallel is recorded in John regarding the
case of Lazarus of Bethany where "Jesus said, 'Remove the stone.' Martha,
the sister of the deceased, said to Him, 'Lord, by this time there will be
a stench, for he has been dead four days.'" (John
11:39). The entombment of Jesus in a temporary grave occurred just
before the
annual Sabbath began. On that holyday the chief priests and Pharisees
sought placement of a guard at the tomb (Matthew
27:62-65, cf.
Luke 24:21).
Pilate, approving, ordered the tomb to made secure by sealing the tomb
entry and by posting guards until the third day was past (Matthew
27:66). The women, therefore, could not enter the tomb, until the
fourth day whether the body had a stench or not.
Moreover, consider
Luke 23:55-56, which reads "Now the women who had come with Him out of
Galilee followed, and saw the tomb and how His body was laid. Then they
returned and prepared spices and perfumes. And on the Sabbath they rested
according to the commandment". First, as Torah compliant Jews they could
not have prepared spices and perfumes on the annual Sabbath for that would
have been forbidden work. Second, the text indicates that the women rested
on the Sabbath following their preparation of spices and perfumes.
Unequivocally this context requires a Thursday annual Sabbath, a Friday
when the women purchased and prepared spices and perfumes, and the weekly
Sabbath. |
|
|
|