Perspectives

Up
Search Site
Contents
Books'n Mor
Overview
Concepts & Theory
Levantine Fieldwork
The First Christians
Questions & Answers
Perspectives
Critical Perspectives
Feature Articles
Biblical Chronology
The Levant
Music &The Bible
Helps & Aids
Travel & Touring
Words & Phrases
Photo Gallery
Useful Links
Who We Are
Our History & Purpose
Works Cited
What We Believe
Article Submissions
How to Cite BibArch
How to Contact Us

Click here to send us Questions or Comments

Copyright � 1997-2004
High Top Media

All Rights Reserved.

Legal Notices

 

For October-December 2001
Volume 4 Number 4

[ Home ] [ More Editions of Perspectives ] [ Our Feature Article ] [ Comments from Viewers ] [ Questions & Answers ]

This page provides a place for editorials, the opinion of our editors and viewers, answers to short questions from our viewers, and occasional feature articles. You can also access previous editions by using the More Editions of Perspectives link.

Our Feature Article

Costume and Dress in
Early Christian Art

The artistic portrayal of characters in mythical and biblical scenes in contemporary costume followed Greco-Roman artistic traditions. A striking feature of the dress of biblical figures in early Christian art is ordinariness.

by Norman A. Rubin

Just as in contemporary society, dress was important during the early Christian era under Roman and Byzantine rule hemogeny. It is, therefore, important that we have some understanding of the variations of apparel when considering the way in which early Christians clothed themselves. In this way we will understand the methods used by the early Christian artists in depicting biblical figures.

Sources for our knowledge of dress in late antiquity include wall paintings, monumental reliefs, mosaics, sarcophagi, painted portraits (mainly Egyptian), and even some actual garments, i.e., fragments of, garments and a sandal excavated from the Bar Kochba Caves in the Judean Desert,F1 contemporary texts, literary references from Greek and Roman historical records and Talmudic literatureF2, throw light on the type of dress and their social significance.

All these connotations played an important part in Early Christian art. It is notable that with a few exceptions all the figures shown are wearing contemporary Greco-Roman costume depiction. i.e. A fresco from the CE 3rd century synagogue of Durra Europas in SyriaF3 shows Samuel anointing David dressed in colorful knee-length tunics.

Costume-10.jpg (312950 bytes)

Roman Costume. Left to right.  Youth, philosopher, first empress, first emperor, second emperor, lictor, second empress, senator. Bilderatlas.

Upper Class Men

Costume-1.jpg (298755 bytes)The most important item of dress worn by the upper class men was the toga, which had originally been the typical attire of all the notable Roman citizens. In a fresco from Pompeii, Campania, Italy depicting the parody of the Judgment of Solomon, the king wears a toga thus representing himself as a magistrate.

In the early Christian era, the garment that conveyed prestige was the himation, consisting of a rectangular piece of cloth thrown over the left shoulder and wrapped around the body. This may be why many artists depict biblical characters, such as Abraham and Moses wearing the himation than the toga; it conveyed a sense of dignity and importance.F4

Costume-3.jpg (316654 bytes)During the cold of the winter months the upper classes covered their clothing with a chlamys, a short, fine woolen mantle. It became the symbol of the upper classes and the rulers. Some, in the mountainous regions draped themselves with a lacerna, a rectangular woolen cloak with rounded corners and a hood. Surviving fragments were found in the Bar Kokhba Caves.

Lower Class Men

Costume-7.jpg (216894 bytes)Early Christian artists depicted Jesus and the Apostles in the dress of the lower classes to convey the message that they were among the common people. In the artistic depictions of the Jesus as the Good Shepherd, His dress was of a simple nature. The main item of dress was the was a short sleeved tunic know as the colobium.

Other garments worn by the lower classes included the burrus, a rectangular cloak of thick coarse wool with a hood, and the paenula, a semicircular cloak, fastened in the front, often with a hood, used by men for traveling. A garment for formal wear was the abolla, draped over the clothing; it was rectangular, made of wool, fastened with a decorative pin, and worn in a double fold over the right shoulder.

Barbarian Costume

Costume-11.jpg (195223 bytes)

People of Gaul in Costume. Bilderatlas.

Another distinction during the Roman era was the between the civilized inhabitants of the empire and the barbarians who lived near the borders or beyond the realm. Though feared for their strange uncouth ways and their constant threat to Rome, they were also fascinatingly exotic in their dress.

In Gaul and Germany, although the upper crest of society adopted the Roman dress when attending their senate. Whereas the local peasantry retained their traditional Germanic and Celtic dress - for men it consisted of a bracae, long tight trousers, a long-sleeved tunic, and a cloak fastened by a fibula on their shoulders. Both the cloak and bracae were woven in checked patterns, similar to the Scots' designs of today.

Costume-8.jpg (99422 bytes)

Parthian Dress. Bilder-
atlas.

In the East, some members of the upper class wore Parthian dress loose trousers inside half boots and long-sleeved tunics - the tunics of the upper class were usually embroidered in gold floral patterns on the front on the sleeves. A tall, cylindrical polos hat completed the dress. Roman artists continued to picture this dress to indicate the Eastern barbarian. In the contemporary version of Eastern dress, biblical figures such as Solomon sitting in judgment, is represented as an oriental ruler dressed in the 'bracace' and a long embroidered tunic.

Upper and Lower Class Women

Costume-4.jpg (849804 bytes) Israelite women depicted by the early artists and historians were usually dressed in a simple chiton, an ankle-length tunic, with or without sleeves. The sleeves were generally fastened with a pin and the tunic was gathered in by a belt below the breasts. Over this women would wear a pallai or himation, a woolen mantle dyed in various colors or adorned with a pattern. It was used to cover the head, when walking in the streets, as a sign of modesty, or with men during religious ceremonies. Simple thonged leather sandals completed the dress.

The figure of Mary, is shown in artistic renditions, draped with this garment, modestly drawn over her head in the manner of the respectable matrona (upper-class women).

Jewish and Christian Costume

The main sources for our knowledge of the various types of clothing worn by the Hebrews of that era is through Talmudic literature; the Bar Kokhba archaeological finds of a thonged sandal, garments and textiles; and pictured on the Dura-Europos frescoes.

There was no specifically Jewish costume depicted. The patriarchs as well as rabbinical figures were pictured in the attire of Roman dignitaries. There were, however, some details that would depict an individual as a Jew - fibers such as wool and linen would never be mixed together according to the biblical edict (shaiatnez) forbidding the mixture of fibers in a single cloth. Also, men would have worn tsistsit, ritual fringes on the corners of their mantles.

In the Talmudic era a Jewish man would of worn a haluq, a short tunic, decorated with clavi, stripes, and a talith, a shaw-like garment of wool (or linen) with fringes at the four corners, worn during religious services. Jewish women wore long tunics and loose, sleeveless cloak or cape that resembled the pallai or ihimationi. Decoration was usually the gamma-shaped patterns, probably of the similar design of Roman Egypt.

Costume-9.jpg (114221 bytes)

Religious Dress. Left to right. Capuchin monk, Calmalduensian monk, Capuchin monk, and Valombrose monk. Bilder-
atlas
.

The Christian clergy wore the collumbium and after the third century, the dalmatica and the stola was adopted (these ancient garments survive in Catholic and other Christian dress.)F5 The stola has metamorphosed into the stole, a strip of silk or other material hanging from the back of the neck over the left shoulder and down to the knees. The dalmatica has become the dalmatic, a wide-sleeved, long-loosed vestment with slit sides, worn at religious rites. There is also the tunicle, derived from the tunica, Roman or Greek tunic, and a chasuble, worn by a priest during the celebration of Mass - from the Roman paenula or casula, a loose sleeveless outer garment. The pallium, a large rectangular mantle worn by men in ancient Greece and Rome, has shrunk into a circular strip of white lamb's wool, worn over the chasuble by the Catholic hierarchy.

Conclusion

One of the striking features of dress of biblical figures in early Christian art is its ordinariness; prominent personages from both the Old and New Testaments, were depicted in clothing similar to each other, be they be Christian, Jew or pagan. Military dress appeared in the paintings - worn by soldier saints such as St. Minas, or warrior kings, such as Herod or Nebuchadnezzar. Prominent figures like David and Saul or Moses were in the attire of contemporary rulers both Hellenistic and Roman; and notably eastern figures such as Daniel or Samson wore exotic barbarian dress.F6

The early Christian artist did not develop the depiction of a recognizable sacred costume for biblical figures, as happened during and after the Renaissance. Did they avoid the iconographical path because of the distaste for the pagan world associated with hostile state officials? Or, did they feel particularly near to the biblical figures they pictured, regarding them as spiritual ancestors and models who could be truly imitated?

Whatever the reason behind the use of contemporary costume, this non-historical dress, to which we have been accustomed to in religious art, still has the power to surprise and delight us.

Bibliography

Cooper, Jean C., An Illustrated Encyclopedia of Traditional Symbols. London: Thames and Hudson, 1978.

A Lion Handbook: History of Christianity. Lion Publishing PLC, 1996.

Westenholtz, Joan Goodnick. "Images of Inspiration", Catalogue. Jerusalem: Bible Lands Museum, n.d.

Comments from Our Viewers

Please send us your Comments by e-mail. All submissions must be signed and include your street or route address and telephone number, which we require for verification purposes only. We reserve the right to use or not use comments so addressed (in whole or in part, as deemed in the public interest), to include your name, and to edit or condense your comments for clarity and space. Click here to send us Comments.

BibArch Site 

Just a quick note to tell you how much I've enjoyed visiting your site ! As a Sunday School teacher I will greatly appreciate the wonderful resources you have. May God continue to richly bless you and your staff.

--Tom Slavicek

Essene Guesthouse?

The Last Seder was held at an Essene guesthouse in Jerusalem? Just what purpose does inventing an Essene connection to Jesus serve? A large dining hall in Jerusalem could just as easily have been owned by a rich man such as Joseph of Arimathea. Shades of George Moore! He wrote a novel called 'The Brook Kerith' in 1916 claiming that Jesus was an Essene who left the commune to start his own ministry, that when he was on the cross only 3 hours Joseph of Arimathea got the Roman centurion to let him down then went to Pilate to ask for his body, and, conducting it to his own newly-built tomb, realized Jesus was still alive, since it usually takes days to die on a cross, not hours. He then snuck back at night, rolled the stone back, carried Jesus to one of his houses, and nursed him back to help, concealing him to prevent recapture by the Romans. This then caused the resurrection myth to spread among his followers. Like I said, why even go there?

--T. L. Winslow

In context, the Gospels show that Jesus observed a Passover Seder 24 hours before the traditional Passover Seder of the Jews. Based upon the current state of scholarly knowledge, unless there were two back-to-back Passover days in the year of the Crucifixion there appears to be no reconciliation of the Gospel accounts. The only known Jewish group to have kept a meatless Passover in Jerusalem's Upper City during the Herodian Period were the Essenes. Our article presented the evidence that Jesus kept his last Seder at the Essene guesthouse. This is a wholly different matter than labeling Jesus an Essene.

Our tentative explanation, based upon the work of Bargil Pixner and other scholars, comes from the available archaeological and literary evidence. Just because you do not like their theory that does not falsify it. Ignoring is not particularly helpful either. In the social sciences, which is the discipline in which archaeology finds itself, falsification of theory enables us to develop improved explanations. This is how knowledge advances in science. If you want hermeneutic-based interpretation, spinning, and fantasy passing as knowledge there are plenty of opinions. For example, R. Steven Notley, writing in Jerusalem Perspective does not like the Essene proposition advanced by Bargil Pixner one whit. Read Notley's poorly researched, illogical, simplistic, and misleading Jesus and the Essene Passover. It is a classic case of theological psuedo-intellectualism -- many words, no evidence, no merit.

--editor

Questions & Answers

Please feel free to submit short questions. We reserve the right to answer and publish those we believe to be in the public interest. We reserve the right to use or not use questions (in whole or in part), to include your name, and to edit or condense your questions for clarity and space. Click here to submit a question to the editor.

Study and Careers in Biblical Archaeology 

I am considering changing careers and am interested in consulting with someone regarding a career in Biblical Archaeology. Are there any online degree programs available in this field?

--Rich Germaine

This site was recommended to me by some one who said that you could answer my questions concerning Biblical Archaeology.  First of all, I an a 14-year-old, home-schooled freshman and I am interested in becoming a biblical archaeologist.  What prep courses would be best to take before collage, would it be wise to go for my doctorate, and what would be the best collage to go to for all this stuff?  I would be very happy if you could answer my questions.  

--Sarah DeVeux

If you really want to become grounded in this field we suggest you explore the programs at Hebrew University of Jerusalem and the University of Tel Aviv. In the USA we doubt you will find a regionally accredited institution with a masters degree in this specialty. Stay away from diploma mills displaying themselves on the WWW claiming that some accrediting association has accredited them. Avoid them like the plague.

The research strategy we suggest is for you to explore area studies programs such as Middle Eastern Studies and Anthropology at large universities. We like Texas A&M at College Station, the University of Arizona, Harvard University, and the University of Chicago. As long as Drs. Lewis R. Binford and David A. Freidel remain at Southern Methodist University we recommend SMU for doctoral studies in archaeology. We see the preoccupation of theological schools with their own denominational biases and hermeneutic much too constrictive for them to deliver a credible scientific approach to biblical archeology but there are exceptions.

If you take the anthropology route you can emphasize old world archaeology in your program and undertake a biblical archaeology thesis topic. If you proceed in a doctoral program you can elect an archeology option and use biblical archaeology as a specialty. In any case, get a second and third opinion.

--editor

The Decree of Artaxerxes

I have been researching the date of when Artaxerxes signed the decree to rebuild Jerusalem of which started the prophetic clock which Jesus would come. I have read many articles and Encyclopedias that say 457 B.C, 445 B.C, 444 B.C. If this is such a important event as many say it is, why are there differences of when it took place? Can you share with me the evidence for which date is correct?

--Kelly Powers

The precise date is unknown. What you see in the literature are approximate dates based upon different analyses and assumptions. Artaxerxes I (465-424 BCE) ruled Persia while Nehemiah was governor of Judah and the time of the activities of Ezra the scribe. Ezra 7:11-26 tells of the decree of Artaxerxes, ca. 458 BCE, permitting the Jews to return to Eretz Israel and engage in worship. Nehemiah 2:1-8 tells of the issuance of letters by Artaxerxes in ca. 445 BCE to Nehemiah authorizing the rebuilding of Jerusalem. Archaeologists have not discovered these documents. Hence, the Hebrew Scriptures remain the sole record of them. The chronology remains uncertain.

--editor

The Gold of the Exodus 

Thanks for a such an informative website! It is truly a blessing. i recently read a book ''The Gold of Exodus''. It is about the true mount Sinai located in Saudi Arabia. Will I be able to find out more on this subject in the future?

--Ricky Simmons; Skippers, Virginia

You refer to The Gold of Exodus, by Howard Blum, a pop-archaeology adventure story about the Bob Cornuke and Larry Williams expedition to locate Mount Sinai in Saudi Arabia. A major motion picture based on The Gold of Exodus, from a script written by John Sayles, is in production by Castle Rock Entertainment, Warner Bros. Studios.  The book and the forthcoming movie are entertainment not science. It is pop-archaeology and a lot of fun. Details of the exploits of these adventures and their current undertakings is at the BASE Institute Web site.

For biblical scholars, whose adventures are usually no further than the nearest library or conference, the question of where the true Mount Sinai lies is a matter of dispute, as is the Exodus itself, and the Conquest of Canaan. As a biblical archaeologist I endorse scientific explanation developed through the methods of science. 

If we assume that the Israelites left Egypt precisely as described in the Hebrew Scriptures, a very literal approach, then we would have the parting of the Red Sea by a miracle ca. 1443 BCE. The Israelites would have proceeded inland over a period of several weeks to Mt. Horeb (Exodus 3:1, 3:12). A population of the magnitude suggested in the Hebrew Scriptures, probably well over a million men, women, and children, plus their cattle, sheep, and other animals, and the like, would move fairly slowly. The simplest answer would then be that the Mt. Horeb of Moses' day was on the present day Sinai Peninsula.

In hermeneutics, as opposed to science, literally scores of possible routes of the Israelites and Mt. Horeb are possible. The advocates of various theories select ancient literary accounts, quote authorities (usually those they agree with), and argue selected archaeological discoveries to support their opinion. This is not science. The approach only brings about more argument and more questions not understanding, fact, and truth.

Scientific analysis of the Exodus route, still assuming a literal one as reported in the Hebrew Scriptures, through biblical archaeology is quite difficult. Nomadic peoples leave very little surviving material culture to excavate. They didn't manufacture the pottery and build the villages,  towns, and settlements that we can excavate today. That does not mean that there is no evidence. One day we will develop more information about this matter and place it on bibarch.com. Our opinion, for whatever that is worth, is that the biblical Mt. Horeb is today the place called Jabal Musa or Gebal Musa in the southern Sinai Peninsula. Nevertheless, I plan to view The Gold of Exodus movie as I enjoy a good adventure too. 

--editor

Early Date for the Exodus

I believe in the early date for the Exodus (1440's B.C.). Why in the Bible in Exodus does it refer to the building of the cities of Rameses? Do you have an explanation for this?

--George Kann

We appear to be dealing with a retrospective usage or modernization of an older name similar to the name Dan in Genesis 14:24 used instead of the older name Laish (Kaiser 1990:289). 

--editor

Page last edited: 11/28/04 08:44 AM

Does the national archive and treasury of the kings of Judah lie hidden deep underground in the ancient City of David?

NEW

The tomb of King David has been lost since the days of Herod the Great. Have archaeologists and historians now isolated its location? New research suggests the tomb, and a national archive and treasury containing unbelievable wealth, lies not far south of the Haram esh-Sharif. You will find the implications astounding.


What was Jerusalem in the days of Herod and Jesus really like?

Tradition places Herod's Temple on the Haram esh-Sharif. Is this really the site of the Temple in Jesus' day? A new carefully detailed compilation and analysis of the historical evidence says -- absolutely not!

View Temple Video


The Old City of Jerusalem

This small sample section of a beautiful map from the Survey of Israel, suitable for framing, is a must for serious students of the Bible. The map sets forth the topography of the city and provides labels for all major

 

Thank you for visiting BIBARCH
Please Visit Our Site Often

rsaclabel.gif (1938 bytes)

Rated in the
Top 10% of Websites
by WebsMostLinked

Rated Outstanding andbest starting web/internet resource by the

sw_award.gif (5126 bytes)

Chosen by librarians at O'Keefe Library, St. Ambrose University, for inclusion in The Best Information on the Net.